Charged in Virginia Court, Then Charged by the Feds? How State and Federal Cases Collide

By Daniel Rouleau, Esq.

Most people think a crime gets one case in one courtroom. That is not always true. Some actions break both Virginia law and federal law at the same time. When that happens, you can face two separate prosecutions: one by the Commonwealth of Virginia and one by the United States. And when the federal government steps in, the stakes usually go up fast.

Two Governments, Two Sets of Laws

Virginia and the federal government each write their own criminal laws. Many crimes overlap. Common examples include:

• Drug distribution, especially larger amounts or cases crossing state lines

• Gun charges, such as a felon possessing a firearm

• Robbery of a bank or business tied to interstate commerce

• Fraud, identity theft, and internet or child-exploitation crimes

• Violent crimes connected to gangs or drug trafficking

In these cases, local police, the Virginia State Police, and federal agents (like the FBI, DEA, or ATF) often work together. A case that starts in a county courthouse can end up in federal court.

Isn’t That Double Jeopardy?

Many people are surprised to learn the answer is usually no. The U.S. Constitution says you cannot be tried twice for the “same offence.” But the U.S. Supreme Court has long held that a state and the federal government are separate “sovereigns.” A crime against each one counts as two different offenses. The Supreme Court reaffirmed this rule in 2019, in a case where a man convicted of a gun charge in state court was then prosecuted for the same gun under federal law.

So under the U.S. Constitution, both governments can come after you for the same conduct.

Virginia Adds Some Protection

Virginia law offers an extra shield that many states do not. Under Va. Code § 19.2-294, if the same act violates both a state and a federal statute, a federal prosecution can bar a later Virginia prosecution for that act. But this protection has limits:

• It applies to the same act, not just a similar crime or the same investigation.

• Timing matters. The federal case generally must get underway before the state case begins.

• It does not stop the federal government from charging you after a Virginia case. Only federal law and federal policy control that.

Federal prosecutors also have internal guidelines that discourage bringing federal charges after a state case for the same conduct, unless they believe an important federal interest was left unaddressed. These guidelines are not a legal right, and exceptions are common.

Why Federal Cases Often Take Over

In practice, when a case is big enough to interest federal prosecutors, the federal case often takes the lead. Commonwealth (or state) charges are frequently dropped once a federal indictment comes down. That may sound like good news. It usually is not. Here is why:

• Tougher sentences. Many federal drug and gun crimes carry mandatory minimum prison terms. Judges must also calculate the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines.

• No parole. Federal parole was abolished decades ago. Federal inmates can earn, at most, about 54 days of good-conduct credit per year under 18 U.S.C. § 3624(b), so most of the sentence is served.

• Bigger resources. Federal agencies have more money, more agents, crime labs, wiretaps, and time. Federal cases are often built over months before anyone is arrested.

• High conviction rates. The large majority of federal defendants plead guilty, and few go to trial.

• Distant prisons. A federal sentence may be served in a facility far from home and family.

The Death Penalty Question

Virginia abolished the death penalty effective July 1, 2021. No one can be sentenced to death under Virginia law today. The federal government is different. Under the Federal Death Penalty Act, 18 U.S.C. § 3591 and related sections, certain federal crimes can still carry a death sentence. These include some murders tied to drug trafficking, terrorism, kidnapping, and other serious federal offenses.

That means a homicide case that could never be a death-penalty case in a Virginia court can become one if federal prosecutors take it and the facts fit a federal capital crime. Federal prosecutors must give formal notice before seeking death, and those cases require specially qualified defense counsel. Still, the possibility alone changes everything about how a case must be defended.

What This Means for You

If you are charged with a serious felony in Virginia, do not assume your case will always stay in state court. Early decisions can affect whether federal prosecutors get involved. Talking to investigators or making statements without counsel can hurt you in both systems.

Talk to Rouleau Law

If you or a loved one is facing criminal charges in a Virginia court, contact Rouleau Law, PLLC. We serve Pittsylvania County, Danville, Halifax County, Henry County, Martinsville, and Patrick County.

Please note: Rouleau Law handles Virginia state charges only. We do not currently represent clients in federal court. If federal charges are filed against you, you will need an attorney admitted to practice in that federal court.

Rouleau Law, PLLC

9 Payne Street, Chatham, Virginia 24531

(434) 933-0022

RouleauLawVA.com

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Laws change, and the information here may not reflect the most current law. Do not act or refrain from acting based on this article without consulting a licensed attorney about your specific situation. Daniel Rouleau, Esq., Rouleau Law, PLLC, 9 Payne Street, Chatham, Virginia 24531, is responsible for this content.

Next
Next

Not Your Typical DUI: Sleeping Pills, Hard Drugs, and Hallucinogens Behind the Wheel in Virginia